Register | Forums | Log in

No more miracles as A's fall to Tigers 6-0

Oakland Athletics catcher Derek Norris looks down as Detroit Tigers second baseman Omar Infante scores after Miguel Cabrera was hit with a pitch with the bases loaded in the seventh inning during Game 5 of the ALDS in Oakland on Thursday, October 11, 2012.

CHRISTOPHER CHUNG / The Press Democrat
Published: Thursday, October 11, 2012 at 3:00 a.m.
Last Modified: Friday, October 12, 2012 at 9:47 a.m.

OAKLAND — The team that made a delirious campaign out of overcoming adversity finally found an obstacle it couldn't clear. His name is Justin Verlander, and he's the best pitcher in baseball.

Verlander took the air out of the resilient A's at O.co Coliseum on Thursday, painting the knees with sizzling fastballs, dropping curves and sliders onto the paint, and keeping everyone off-balance with an unfair changeup in decisive Game 5 of this American League division series. He threw a complete-game shutout, allowing just four hits and a single walk, and striking out 11 in the Detroit Tigers' 6-0 victory.

“When Verlander gets on a roll like he was today, especially when he gets into his rhythm, you get into the middle innings and he's rolling along pretty good, it's tough to stop him,” A's manager Bob Melvin said. “It's like a locomotive going at a high speed.”

The Athletics captivated baseball fans everywhere with their dramatic finishes this year. But down by a couple, then a bunch, their only walk-off Thursday was a slow trudge off the diamond. They re-emerged from the dugout to tip their caps to the 36,393 fans who cheered them to the final out, a grounder to second base by Seth Smith, and the boos raining down on the celebrating Tigers quickly turned to cheers and chants of “Let's go, Oakland!”

Even the Tigers came over to acknowledge the A's, whose 25-man roster included 12 rookies.

Verlander began this series by surrendering a leadoff home run to Coco Crisp last Saturday. It proved to be a tease for the A's. The pitcher went seven innings in that game and gave up just two more hits, and in Game 5 he picked up right where he left off.

Judging by his work against the A's, the Detroit ace seems to have regained his place as the game's dominant pitcher. There was no doubt of his status in 2011, when his off-the-charts season — 24-5, 2.40 ERA, 250 strikeouts in 251 innings — won him not just the AL Cy Young award, but the league MVP as well.

This year, he fell to 17-8, though his ERA (2.64) and strikeouts (239) didn't show much drop-off. He's a candidate for more Cy Young hardware, along with the Angels' Jared Weaver, Seattle's Felix Hernandez and Tampa Bay's David Price. After Thursday, it's hard to imagine any of those guys being better than Verlander. Ask Oakland shortstop Stephen Drew, who struck out four times Thursday.

Verlander threw a dazzling variety of pitches, and got all of them over for strikes. He started each of his first four innings with strikeouts, setting the tone against a team that likes to work the pitch count.

“He's got four pitches that he can throw for strikes. He has four pitches that he commands,” Alex Avila, Verlander's catcher, said between puffs of a cigar in the champagne-drenched winners' locker room. “That makes it extremely difficult for a hitter. A lot of times as a hitter, when you put a game plan together, you figure out what the pitcher's best pitches are. You try to attack his weaknesses. He doesn't have any.”

Jarrod Parker, one of three rookies in the A's starting rotation for this series, pitched well in Game 5 but was nowhere near as dominant as Verlander.

With the game scoreless, Parker stumbled in the third inning. Omar Infante led off with a single, went to second base on a wild pitch that dribbled just in back of catcher Derek Norris, and scored on Austin Jackson's double that tailed away from center fielder Crisp. Quintin Berry sacrificed the runner to third, and Jackson scored on another wild pitch that put Detroit up 2-0.

Parker settled down after the second wild pitch, retiring 10 of the next 11 batters, with only a walk to Infante dirtying the mark. But he got in trouble again in the seventh, giving up singles to Jhonny Peralta and Infante, and that was it for Parker.

“To be able to match (Verlander) tonight was gonna be a pretty tough feat,” Parker said.

Things went to hell in his absence. Ryan Cook gave up an RBI single to Jackson, walked Berry on four pitches and, after getting ahead of Miguel Cabrera 0-2, plunked the Triple Crown winner on the elbow to force in a run. Jerry Blevins took his turn, and gave up a run-scoring single to Prince Fielder, followed by a hard-hit grounder that got past Drew at shortstop for an error and another run.

Verlander lost only a little velocity through his nine innings. With two outs in the seventh, he got slugger Josh Reddick on three consecutive four-seam fastballs — the last one at 95 miles per hour.

The Tigers advance to face the winner of the Yankees-Orioles series. The A's will let the loss sink in, then ponder an amazing season that included 94 wins in the regular season and the team's first AL West championship since 2006.

“We didn't think it would end today, not for a second,” Melvin said.

“We knew we were going up against a good pitcher, but that didn't mean we didn't think we were going to win. ... It's a bit of a shock when it finally does end. It was a heck of a story. It was a heck of a run for us.”

You can reach Staff Writer Phil Barber at 521-5263 or phil.barber@pressdemocrat.com.

All rights reserved. This copyrighted material may not be re-published without permission. Links are encouraged.

▲ Return to Top